Z*Net: 16-Mar-90 #511

From: Len Stys (aa399@cleveland.Freenet.Edu)
Date: 03/21/90-12:01:51 PM Z

From: aa399@cleveland.Freenet.Edu (Len Stys)
Subject: Z*Net: 16-Mar-90  #511
Date: Wed Mar 21 12:01:51 1990

                     //////       //    //  //////  //////   
                        //   /   ///   //  //        //   
                     //    ///  // // //  //////    //
                  //       /   //   ///  //        //
                 //////       //    //  ///////   //
                Atari Online Magazine          Issue #511
                Copyright (=) 1990 Rovac Industries, Inc.
                            Post Office Box 59
                       Middlesex, New Jersey 08846
                       Publisher/Editor - Ron Kovacs
             Z*Net Online 24 Hour BBS (201) 968-8148  3/12/24
 CompuServe 71777,2140                                       GEnie Z-NET
                    MARCH 16, 1990  Volume 5 Number 11
                          * TABLE OF CONTENTS *
     .......................................................Ron Kovacs
     Latest Atari News and more.......................................
     Exclusive Report.......................................Jon Clarke
     Challenge and Opportunity................................Leo Sell
     Review..............................................Keith MacNutt
     New PD releases reviewed..............................Alice Amore
     More PD releases reviewed..............................Mark Quinn
     Reader Commentary............................Elliott John Coerper
     Letters to the editor..................................Ron Kovacs
                        THIS WEEK - by Ron Kovacs
 You and your user group or friends can have a FREE box full of brand new
 back issues of ST-XPRESS for just the cost of shipping!
 SPROCKETS is a new ST hardware and software development company in Los
 Angeles, and it has taken over the old storage area belonging to ST-
 XPRESS MAGAZINE... and there are LOTS of full boxes of back issues that
 MUST GO.  Z*NET has talked SPROCKETS into offering the magazines to user
 groups and readers of Z*NET Online rather than allow them to be
 destroyed.  ST-XPRESS was a respected, quality slick newsstand magazine
 supporting the Atari ST from 1986 through November 1989, when they
 released their final issue.

 SPROCKETS will be happy to send you or your group a full box of issues
 if you send an address plus a short written statement saying that you
 will accept the C.O.D. Ground Shipping charges through United Parcel
 Service.  You should expect this charge to be $8 to $15 at most for
 typical locations.  REMEMBER, UPS will NOT ship to POST OFFICE BOXES.

 Each box typically contains 50 copies of a single issue, and many
 different issues are available... but PLEASE don't ask for specific
 months or mixed issue boxes!  If you want more than one box, we CAN be
 sure to ship you a different month in each box.  MOST boxes are of the
 later issues... and a few might even come with the subscription disks in

 Remember, this offer is basically to see to it that these old issues of
 ST-XPRESS can go to some good use.  SPROCKETS has volunteered to ship
 them without labor charges if your group will cover the shipping C.O.D.

 If you want a box (or several!) for your club or friends, send a card or
 letter RIGHT AWAY to:

     417B Foothill Blvd
     Suite 381
     Glendora, California

 This offer is open to any Z*NET readers and expires when the supply of
 magazines is exhausted or on April 15, whichever comes first.


                              Z*NET NEWSWIRE

 Atari has discussed and announced the intention to exert more control
 over scheduling of Atari shows that request Atari's involvement.  After
 some hard lessons last year that resulted in the cancellation of both
 user and commercial shows due to time conflicts, Atari now intends to
 firmly stand behind a policy of NO SHOWS WITHIN 30 DAYS OF OTHER SHOWS.
 On the agenda at this time are the upcoming World of Atari show in
 Disneyland April 7-8, the Glendale (Los Angeles) Atarifest in early
 September, and the WAACE (Virginia/DC) Atarifest in late September.
 These last two shows are to be the last that will be allowed to violate
 the 30 day rule, as they were both scheduled before User Group
 Coordinater Bob Brodie was available for involvement.  The 30 day
 spacing will allow vendors and developers more time to prepare for shows
 and will likely make ALL shows stronger.  Atari might soon want to
 "write in" the two CES and COMDEX shows, the annual HANNOVER show, and
 at least the January NAMM shows.  These events certainly are as draining
 as Atarifests on both Atari and third-party developers.  User Groups 
 interesting in setting up show dates are encouraged to call Bob Brodie 
 at Atari (408) 745-2052, to insure no scheduling conflicts.
 Charles Cherry, Atari Corp Developer Support mogul, says that the
 SOFTSOURCE Program is ready to premier on a major telecommunications
 network.  The system is 100% completed and is in private testing to be
 sure that it is fully operational when it is formally introduced in
 April.  Softsource will be an online database and library of commercial
 software in demo form, available for download and inspection by any
 user.  The concept is to have EVERY COMMERCIAL PROGRAM AVAILABLE
 ANYWHERE included in the collection, along with online interactive
 support and indexing.  A user will eventually be able to key in a few
 parameters and be offered a list of candidates for program selection.
 Choose French Revolution wargame simulations, or scientific graphing
 applications, or whatever... and be able to actually try the choices
 before you buy.  Shortly after Softsource premiers online, it will be
 pressed onto CD-ROM disks and be available at Atari Dealers for fast
 free examination of the entire collection.  The disks themselves will
 likely be made available for next to nothing for home perusal... once
 the Atari CD ROM is commercially released.  That blessed event is likely
 to follow the dealer program by a few months... with luck!

 TOUCH-UP is a terrific image editor, plus a scanner interface,
 originally designed for the Atari ST by MIGRAPH.  Now, Migraph has
 completed the port of the popular graphic editor to the IBM platform,
 and shipping began last week.  A special is in effect for a limited
 time, giving you the IBM TOUCH-UP for only $174 plus $5 shipping...
 discounted from the regular $199.  If you have experienced TOUCH-UP on
 the ST at home, suggest it for the IBM at work!  MIGRAPH, (206)838-4677.

 A groundbreaking lawsuit involving charges of defamation via
 international telecommunications message systems was settled by a Court
 Order that also forbids the parties to discuss the details.  Dave Small
 of Gadgets By Small was sued by Richard Adams of Happy Computer over
 statements posted as messages on GEnie last year.  Adams contended that
 the statements were false and defamatory to him and his products,
 notably to the DISCOVERY CARTRIDGE copy device.  Small was equally upset
 over Adams' inclusion and subsequent republication in an online magazine
 of plans on how to use the Discovery Cart to eliminate the need of the
 Spectre Cart, the Macintosh emulator from Gadgets.  This week, Small
 said that the suit had been settled "amicably" (stressing that it was
 "really, really amicable") but that he was forbidden by agreement from
 discussing the terms of the settlement.  It is known that HAPPY is
 moving quickly towards the IBM market for their future product line, and
 it may be that Adams no longer is as ready to fight over an Atari-
 specific disagreement.

 Late word from TWO locations both point to the 68030 computer(s) to be
 shown at the Anaheim World of Atari... one from Atari (the TT) and one
 from Dave Small.  According to Sam Tramiel, every effort should be made
 to show the Atari TT at the show despite the fact that it is not yet
 ready for production.  And Gadgets by Small will be showing their
 prototype 68030 CPU replacement board at the same show.  Dave Small's
 project is a GADGETS production with consulting by Jim Allen Jr. of FAST
 TECHNOLOGIES, and may or may not ever actually make it to commercial
 production.  However, Dave says it is REAL NOW, it WORKS, and the next
 step is to make the first printed circuit boards for more testing.  Able
 to accommodate CPU speeds as high as 32MHZ (with EXPENSIVE support high
 speed RAM), or more economical but still pricey 16MHZ chips, the Small
 68030 will make ANY ST or MEGA into a speed demon, almost an order of
 magnitude faster than the current machine.  It WON'T make it into a TT,
 tho... for that, you need Atari itself.

 Atari announced last week that income from continuing operations of
 $5.8 million or 10 cents per share on sales of $170.6 million for the
 quarter ended Dec. 31, 1989.  This compares with income of $9.3 million
 on sales of $152.6 million for the fourth quarter ended Dec. 31, 1988.
 Net income was $5.7 million in the fourth quarter of 1989 as compared to
 a loss of $97 million last year.  The results for the quarter reflect
 continued revenue growth from the Atari ST and Atari PC4 MS-DOS
 compatible product lines, and from initial shipments of the new handheld
 Portfolio computer and Lynx handheld color video game machine.  During
 the quarter, sales of certain products were facilitated by lowering
 prices in order to make room for new product lines.   Subsequent to year
 end, Atari consummated the sale of certain Southern California leasehold
 interests held by its discontinued Federated Group unit.  No additional
 losses are anticipated on final disposition of Federated.  Sam Tramiel,
 president and chief executive officer, stated: "For Atari, 1989 was a
 transition year.  It witnessed the introduction of a new generation of
 handheld machines -- the Lynx and Portfolio; and, the disposition of an
 extraneous business segment.  For 1990, Atari is fully committed to
 regaining market share in the video game sector with products like the
 Lynx, increasing our market share in the personal computer sector with
 products like the Atari STE, and maximizing our opportunity in the
 handheld or palmtop computer business with Portfolio."

 The U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington D.C. has ruled that
 Nintendo may sue retailers who sell unauthorized cartridges manufactured
 by Atari Games/Tengen Inc. for use with the Nintendo Entertainment
 System (NES) and which Nintendo asserts infringe its patents.  This
 decision vacates a preliminary injunction previously granted to Atari
 Games by the U.S. District Court in Northern California, which enjoined
 suits against retailers who deal in infringing cartridges pending the
 outcome of litigation between Nintendo and Atari Games/Tengen Inc.
 Nintendo has consistently asserted that the manufacture and sale of
 unlicensed video game cartridges by Atari Games violated a number of
 Nintendo's rights, including certain patents Nintendo has obtained on
 its Nintendo Entertainment System and associated game cartridges.  Last
 February, Atari Games obtained a preliminary injunction preventing
 Nintendo from suing Atari Games' dealers for patent infringement, by
 arguing that Nintendo had improperly monopolized the video game
 marketplace by asserting its patent rights and by supervising the
 production of game cartridges for its Nintendo Entertainment System.
 The Court of Appeals found "nowhere does the district court make a
 finding that Atari could probably prove its allegations.  The district
 court has not referred to a factual basis for its granting of the
 preliminary injunction against Nintendo and this court cannot find
 one."  The appeals court stated that "... the record fails to reflect
 that Atari came forth with any evidence... to prove that Nintendo was
 enforcing its patent in bad faith, or expanding its patent rights beyond
 their proper scope."  Furthermore, the court said, "This court cannot
 find, either in the district court's opinion, or anywhere in the record,
 specific factual findings, or the basis for any findings, concerning
 Nintendo's licensing agreement running afoul of the antitrust laws..."
 In fact, the court said, "Many of the restrictions Nintendo places on
 its licensees are not, as a matter of law, antitrust violations."

 GEnie has added an IBM Product Support RoundTable for online access to
 various vendors of IBM PC and compatible software and services.  The
 following are currently providing online support and information in the
 -- The Software Link
    provides multiuser operating systems (PC-MOS), and LAN products.
 -- Volkswriter, Inc.
    markets a line of word processing software including Volkswriter.
 -- Computer Technologies Online
    offers support for Mitsubishi, Osicom, and The Complete PC. 
 -- Spectra Software
    the publisher of PowerBASIC, a full-featured programming environment.
 -- ISD
    provides DynaCADD, a new CADD program for the IBM PC and compatibles.
    In the coming months, ISD will be porting its best-selling software
    for the Atari ST to the IBM platform.
 Each of the five current participating vendors will have a dedicated
 Bulletin Board area in the IBM Product Support RoundTable where messages
 will be posted covering news and rumors as well as technical questions
 and answers by all members.  A software library is also available where
 they will post product announcements, technical and application notes,
 and bug fixes which will be available for downloading by GEnie
 subscribers.  For more information on GEnie call, (800) 638-9636.

 The Software Publishers Association has donated $25,000 to Britain's
 Federation Against Software Theft to establish a piracy hotline and
 corporate audit program similar to those set up by the SPA in North
 America.  Last September, the SPA implemented a toll-free hotline (800)
 388-PIR8 to receive reports about piracy.  It now averages about 20
 calls each day, some of which have resulted in lawsuits backed by the
 group's copyright production fund.

 The Software Toolworks has completed the acquisition of Mindscape Inc.
 Mindscape develops and distributes in North America certain game
 cartridges for the Nintendo Entertainment System and develops, publishes
 and distributes a broad line of microcomputer software products for the
 consumer markets, and owns software distributing and publishing
 subsidiaries serving European and Pacific Rim markets.  For the nine
 months ended Sept. 30, 1989, Mindscape had revenues of $27.9 million. 

 The Software Publishers Association announced this week the completion
 of several successful corporate audits.  SPA corporate software audits,
 which often occur in lieu of litigation, involve an analysis of a 
 company's hard-disk directories and a review of their software purchase
 records.  When unauthorized copying has occurred, the audited company
 must destroy any pirated software, purchase legitimate copies and make a
 contribution to the SPA Copyright Protection Fund. 

 Color Dreams Inc. was formed after the suit between Nintendo and Tengen
 (Atari Games Corp.) was filed and is an independent developer and
 publisher of non-infringing Nintendo compatible software games.  Its
 specific goal was to establish a source of non-infringing games for the
 Nintendo Entertainment System.  Information from the suit enabled Color
 Dreams Inc. to successfully create software games and game cartridges
 that do not infringe Nintendo's patents, trademarks and copyrights.
 After close scrutiny by its own corporate counsel and more than one
 independent patent counsel, Color Dreams Inc. produced games that are
 free of infringement.  Color Dreams appears to be the only company
 producing and licensing technology which permits the creation and sales
 of non-infringing Nintendo compatible software.

 It was announced this week that the U.S. District Court for the Northern
 District of California has rendered a decision on damages in the patent
 infringement suit brought by Magnavox against Mediagenic (then
 Activision) in 1982.  In 1986, the court issued a judgment stating that
 the patent in question was valid and that 11 Activision video game
 cartridges had infringed it.  This judgment was affirmed on appeal in
 1988 and a trial on the issue of damages was held in November 1989.  The
 court awarded damages of approximately $3.5 million to Magnavox, based
 on the determination that Mediagenic should pay a 5 percent royalty on
 $70 million of infringing video cartridge sales.  As a result of the
 decision, Mediagenic anticipates a loss for its fourth quarter and for
 the 1990 fiscal year, ending March 31, 1990.

 by Jon Clarke, Auckland, New Zealand
 How do you describe the first ever Atari specific show in the South
 Pacific in a few words?  Well things like "amazing stuff", "fantastic
 presentation", and "wow" come to mind.  After years of not having an
 Atari presence in both Australia and New Zealand computer shows, it is
 good to see them back at the fore-front of technology Down-Under.
 I found out about the Sydney Atari show last Thursday night, two days
 before it opened to the public, and two and a half thousand miles and
 one country away from here.  So it was off to the travel agent to book a
 few Air tickets and at 7:30 Saturday morning our plane touched down in
 Sydney.  The venue for the show was the Queen Victoria Centre.  A
 loverly old building they have renovated, with 4 levels of shopping for
 mum and the kids, while you slip away to level 3 for the Atari show.
 You couldn't help but notice the Atari show as 70% of all the shoppers
 in the Queen Victoria Centre had little plastic bags with the Atari Fuji
 symbol on them.

 From the time you stepped out of the lift, (or climbed the stairs) the
 Atari people were always on hand to help.  The reception area was filled
 with videos playing exerts on Midi, desktop, and the STe.  Once you
 registered and walked into the show, you were breath taken by all the
 activity going on.  It would have taken very little time to do a circuit
 of the show, but it took me and most people over an hour the FIRST time.
 There was so much to see and participate in, from hands on demo's to
 listening pleasure from live bands using midi.

 From the entrance to the pavilion you could see people all huddled over
 some ST's, so off I went to see what the attraction was.  Well it was
 the new STE's doing their stuff in stereo sound and full living colour.
 Atari-OZ have done some amazing demo's for the STE.  Five in total.  The
 one I loved was the stereo sound and graphic demo, which was linked to a
 'Roland' sound system on which the STE controlled the sound output.
 Have you ever heard a Kookaburra (a native Australian Bird) at 100db of
 sound and in stereo.  Real mind blowing stuff.  In fact all the STE
 demo's were of a very high standard indeed.  This is the first time most
 of the Atari users had seen the STE and the Atari reps were being
 inundated with questions.  The STE will be in general release down-under
 by the time you read this.

 This then lead me to another group of people all looking at a large
 colour monitor, and all in laughter as the guys from ACRE Industries
 demoed the first Australian made 'Genlock' for the Atari ST.  They had
 the video camera focused on a chap sitting on a chair and they were
 doing all sorts of things to the guys image on the video screen with
 'Cyber Paint'.  The effects were humourous to say the least and a real
 crowd pleaser.  The 'Genlock', Acre has designed will work with both
 American (NTSC) and Australian (PAL) T.V systems, and at a retail price
 of under $AUS900 it will be a winner for them.  I loved the 'Cyber'
 animation with realtime video , the world of desktop video is truely

 Moniterms!  They were everywhere doing their stuff, from Calamus to
 scanning to word processing.  In the third party suppliers area there
 was a group of hard core DTP people being blown away by 'Outline', and
 a strange voice coming from within.  <Kiwi's notice these things.>
 This was Nathan from 'Ditek', 'ISD' demonstrating CALAMUS and CALAMUS
 OUTLINE.  Needless to say the crowd was amazed at the quality of Outline
 and a little birdy told me at the show, that the first order of
 'Outline' was sold out by Saturday.  Having read the reviews and seen
 the conferences on 'Outline' I was very impressed to see what it did.
 But alas I have an US ST, and they only had the UK software at the show.
 These shows really bring home how small the Atari world is becoming as
 across from the 'Outline' booth was the A.C.E NSW User Group booth, with
 members, and other clubs from all over Australia, including John
 Hutchinson who is currently working in Australia.  A.C.E NSW (New South
 Wales, a state of OZ) were doing demo's of the ST, along with Norm who
 runs the largest PD library in OZ, based in the state of South Australia.
 Now opposite this were some of the star attractions of this show.  An
 Atari TT 030/2 and a Transputer.  The ozzies had a demo they wrote
 running on the Transputer, with outstanding quality.  No wounder these
 are called graphic work horses!  Release date of the TT is to be in May/
 June and the same for the New Transputer.

 You can't go to a show with out getting involved right?  Well come hell
 or high water there was no way Mum, Dad and the kids could get past the
 Lynx booth.  There was this humungous sign introducing the 'Lynx' and a
 chance to win a free 'Lynx' if you got the high score on Blue
 Well here I was with all the others doing a few practice flights, when
 the call to arms came and we were off.  "Well this little hand held game
 machine is sure a winner", I thought as I zoomed around the screen.
 Then all of a sudden our 5 minutes were up and with a score of 14,410, I
 was happy enough.  The winner of the Lynx in the end had a score of over
 48,000 in just 5 minutes playing time.

 Next to all of this came the IBM world of Atari, from the Portfolio to
 the big grunters, all demonstrating their stuff.  I loved the Portfolio
 area and was surprised to learn that the Australian users have been
 developing a lot of software.  Available now is a program called
 'Timelog', and is a must for professional users of the 'Portfolio'.
 This is a complete time management/recording system, and will eliminate
 the need to fill in manual time sheets.  Along with this there has been
 some programs written to do Meter reading, bar-code reading, and with
 several other programs under development for a "Fast wire" type program
 called 'Mac-slave' and 'ST-slave'.  Available later this year will be
 GWbasic, Laplink, Crosstalk, Word Perfect, Lotus Express, a Financial
 Calculator, a scientific calculator, DOS utilities, and a few games like
 Chess, Backgammon, Tetris, and Golfing with Greg Norman.

 Down this part of the hall were all the other demos of STE's, ST's,
 Clones and the likes doing everything you can think of.  In the middle of
 all of this were Lucas and Joe from Austec, a large Atari Dealership
 from Melbourne in the State of Victoria.  They had the Spectre GCR doing
 its thing on the large screen.  Needless to say the MAC owners were in
 awe at the sight of this.  Austec were one of the 3 booths with the
 CDAR504 CD_ROM players, and had some ST public domain CD_ROM's on
 display.  They also had their own hard disks running, one they
 manufacture themselves, a very nice neat little package.

 From here we headed into the Midi area of the show.  This was by far the
 loudest section of the whole show with 'Roland' demonstrating their
 little boxes of tricks that gave the impression the Sydney Philharmonic
 Orchestra, to machine guns, to 10,000 people clapping hands enjoying
 their favourite Pop group.  Well not to be out done by the USA show's,
 Atari-Oz arranged for Simon Lloyd of 'Ice House' fame to be on stage
 most of Saturday for live midi demos, playing their hit music.  Wow it
 was like being at the concert.  Then on Sunday they had 'Sirocio'
 playing live using midi.  I was speaking to Allen from the 'Roland'
 booth about optic drives and the likes, and it seems the in thing in OZ
 at the moment are the 'W.O.R.M' drives, and it is not unusual to have
 over 1 gigabyte of storage for their sound samples.  1 gig!  Jeeze, we
 are in the wrong computer field, guys.  The music from the Atari
 Machines including STacy, and the live stage were out of this world, and
 could have been the whole show in itself.
 Yes, that's right STacy was there in several booths with the midi guys
 and all of us drooling at it.  I thought it might have been a little
 smaller than the T1200 I am writing this on, but no it was not to be.
 But never the less STacy will be on my Christmas shopping list, along
 with 70% of those that attended the show.  The guys from Electric
 Factory had Stacy hooked into their midi equipment.  While Phill from
 Grass Valley (from Western Australia) had one on his stand running that
 popular program Neo-Desk in demo mode.

 Not be out done by the Midi booths there was a little booth next to the
 stage that nearly floored me.  After going to this show I have come to
 the conclusion Australian programs and programers are the WORLDS BEST
 KEPT SECRET.  Here was a ST with a colour monitor and a CD_ROM.  Not to
 much to see equipment wise, but by the time you fought your way through
 the crowd you were presented with Australia's first CD_ROM program.
 Called 'Sound Scope' you can listen and what is more important learn
 about an orchestra, or individual instruments, or even play your
 favorite compact disks. The graphics interface has to be seen to be
 believed.  When your are in the orchestra section you see the Conductor
 leading the sections of the orchestra.  When say the horns section are
 playing, they are highlighted.  It is like being in the balconies in
 Albert Hall, in fact if you close your eyes you may even feel like you
 are there.  This also supports full Stereo and will even run on Stacy,
 this is really amazing stuff.

 Items on display

  o  Atari 520/1040STE   Shipping Now for Australia/New Zealand
  o  Atari STacy         Shipping 1990
  o  Atari TT030/2       Shipping May June 1990 for Australia/New Zealand
  o  Atari Transputer    Shipping Later 1990, although in limited release
  o  Atari CDAR504,CDROM Shipping Now for Australia/New Zealand
  o  Atari Megafiles     Shipping Now
  o  TOS 1.4 Rainbow     Shipping Now for $AUS199 and $NZ199 fitted
  o  Atari Lynx          Shipping Now
  o  Atari Portfolio     Shipping Now
  o  Atari PC range      Shipping Now
  o  Moniterms           Shipping Now
  o  Hawk Flat Scanner   Shipping Now
  o  ISD's Outline       Shipping Now
  o  SoundScope          Shipping now
  o  Timelog             Shipping Now
  o  AGS-20 genlock      Shipping Now
  o  STe Demo's          Available soon from ATARI-OZ look on GEnie.
  o  Transputer Demo     See Atari Australia
  o  Roland-midi         Shipping Now  <great gear>
  o  Music Publishing    Shipping Now
  o  Plus much much more...
 In conclusion I feel the show was by far the best show I have seen in
 our part of the world, and Atari-Oz should be congratulated for their
 effort that went into the show.  The next show will be the Bits'n'Bits
 show here in Auckland on April 26th of this year at the Auckland Expo
 Centre.  This time Atari-NZ will have a booth and be strutting their

 As I said before, I learned about this show on Thursday night with the
 show about to start on Saturday morning 10am Oz time.  Well on the GEnie
 conference with ISD and Atari-Oz, Allistair Campion told me it was on,
 and invited us to attend.  Well the bets were on to whether or not I
 would arrive.  Needless to say a few dollars were flowing at 11am on

                               THE CLUBROOM
 (Editors Note:  The Clubroom is a continuing series of articles written 
 by User Group members subscribing to the Z*Net International Atari 
 Newsletter Supplement.  We ask individuals to write about specific 
 topics their groups perform and seek out original ideas so that we may 
 share them with other Atari User Groups.  The following article appeared 
 in the March 1990 edition of the Z*Net IANS.)
 by Leo Sell
 (Reprinted from Z*Net March 1990 International Atari Newsletter)
 Copyright (c)1990, Rovac Industries, Inc.
 I've been asked to share a little about how my club, the Capitol Hill
 Atari Owner's Society has collected, organized, and profited from our
 disk libraries.  In thinking it over, and discussing the subject, other
 means of producing revenue, used by other clubs also came to mind.
 Perhaps these ideas will trigger other ideas for all of you.

 I'll start with a brief history of the CHAOS Library.  CHAOS, from its
 inception, has been blessed with leaders and volunteers who insisted on
 structure and organization in each aspect of the club.  Our first
 librarian applied the principles with relish (to the disks, not the hot
 dogs).  Instead of a mishmash of programs, stuffed willy-nilly onto
 disks, he insisted (thankfully) on carefully structuring the library -
 Utilities, Games, Demos, and so on.  That structure has been continued
 even as the club grew and began supporting the ST computers.

 Each librarian since, having the structure already established has been
 able to concentrate on collecting new, quality programs, and preserving
 the organization of the library.  With the volume of new programs that
 is sometimes available, we do on occasion offer disks with a mixture of
 programs - a Disk of the Month - in order to get programs right into
 members' hands.  But all of the programs are eventually absorbed into
 the proper library category.

 Not that things stay static.  The ST is so much more capable that our
 librarians have had to expand the categories to reflect it.  And we
 continue to update and collect new public domain and shareware programs.

 By the way, once you've established a structure (or adopt ours), I think
 the most valuable asset you can have is a member who enthusiastically
 collects and checks out new programs.  A member like that is worth their
 weight in disks!

 The long and the short of it is that because of the structure and
 organization established early on, and preserved as time has gone by,
 CHAOS has one of the best organized public domain libraries around.  And
 because we aggressively update and add programs, it's also one of the
 most complete.

 And it has come to make us money in an unexpected way.

 About three years ago, one of our members came up with an idea on how to
 use the library to better advantage.  His suggestion:  rent it out!
 Since CHAOS had a very complete, highly organized disk library, and
 other clubs and individuals might not have the means to put it together,
 or to buy the disks outright, we thought it would be a great way to
 distribute the library in an affordable manner.  Let clubs or
 individuals substitute their own effort in copying on their own media.
 We'd provide a master from which to copy.

 It worked very well from a revenue standpoint and was well received by
 those who rented it.  That was a couple of years ago.  A lot of programs
 have been upgraded or developed since then.  So....we've updated both
 the 8-bit and the ST libraries, and we're once again offering a rental

 If you or your club would like to rent one of the most complete and best
 organized p.d. libraries around, here are the details.  Renting the 8-
 bit is $75 with a $125 deposit;  the ST library is $99 with a $200
 deposit.  Rent both for $150 with a $300 deposit.  And we're not
 forgetting those who rented before - we do offer a special deal for you.
 If you want more information, write: CHAOS Rental, PO Box 16132,
 Lansing, MI 48901.  (End of commercial).
 So why did I title this section, "Innovative Thinking" and what does
 that have to do with other clubs?  My point is this:  pay attention to
 the innovative thinkers in the club.  A number of clubs have used ideas
 like the CHAOS Rental Program to make money and support their
 operations.  Here are a few examples off the top of my head.

 JACS (Jersey Atari Computer Society?), when PrintShop was at the height
 of popularity, worked very hard to collect icons.  As my memory serves
 they ended up with about six disks full.  They marketed them to other
 individuals and user groups for a reasonable fee.  Their hard work saved
 the customers a great deal of trouble and made the club a nice chunk of

 GAG (Genesee Atari Group, Flint Michigan) has capitalized in several
 similar ways.  At various computer shows, I've seen them sell a new (at
 the time) and creative disk labeling program written by a member and
 displayed for maximum impact.  They've also done well simply by
 labelling their disks well at a show and displaying them on sale boards
 where they could be easily seen and inspected.  Lately, some of their
 members have cooperated to make up numerous Blitz cables to sell to ST
 users who would just as soon let someone else do the work.

 CHAOS once made a special deal on a 256k upgrade board for 800XL's.  By
 careful purchase of ram chips, we were able to offer a fantastic deal on
 I hope the point is obvious at this point.  Clubs and their members are
 only limited by their imaginations.  Let 'em loose.  I know sometimes we
 all get a bit burned out.  But, keep your eyes open for opportunity.
 When it arises, latch onto it.  Your club won't make millions, but it
 might make enough to keep operating for another year or two.  It all
 boils down to good ideas and good marketing (strange concept for Atari
 folks, huh!).  GOOD LUCK Atarians.


                MAXIFILE REVIEW -  by Keith MacNutt, TRACE
 (Reprinted from the Puget Sound Atari News, March 1990)
 The Need

 Like the heading says, this program is a complete replacement for the
 Atari desktop.  If any of you have used the desktop that came with the
 ST, you will have found that it does the job, but is lacking in some
 areas.  You can format, copy disks and do file sorts.  However, past
 that, the desktop loses steam.
 Most power users have long found that they could supplement the desktop
 with accessories or programs that reside in the auto folder.  This gets
 the job done - but at a high cost in lost memory.  Each program or
 accessory may only be able to do a small part of the job the user wanted
 done.  But collectively, they take up much more memory than most users
 would like.  The solution would seen to be to take all the bits and
 pieces of all your favorite accessories and auto programs, and put them
 into one efficient little program that did everything while using very
 little memory.

 The Solution

 Well, someone at CodeHead software must have been listening to all the
 users out there because the MAXIFILE program that they've put together
 does just about everything you could want, and more!  And, they only
 need 64K to do it in!

 What's truely remarkable is the fact that the same MAXIFILE program can
 be used as an accessory or as a program.  For those of you who are new
 to the ST this means that if it is loaded as an accessory (.ACC), you
 will find it under the fuji symbol (or DESK option) on the menu bar.
 Thus, MAXIFILE can be used at any time you are able to access the
 accessory feature from within a program.  However, if you are short of
 memory, then you can run the program (.PRG) version.  And, after
 completing your task, the program will exit and all memory is returned
 to the user.

 MAXIFILE comes on a single side disk with: MAXIFILE.PRG, MAXIFILE.ACC,
 a readme file explaining recent changes, and a folder that contains the
 shareware programs PINHEAD (which speeds up the loading of programs) and
 LGSELECT (which is a replacement file selector).  If you use LGSELECTOR
 and you have MAXIFILE loaded as an accessory then you can access
 MAXIFILE directly by clicking on the selector box provided by LGSELECT.

 This is the area that the user sets the source and destination pathways.
 To change either source or destination pathway you would click on either
 word and pick the drive letter from the highlighted selector box.  This
 same operation can be preformed by hitting "s" for source or "d" for
 destination.  If you have favorite pathways that you use frequently then
 you may want to save those in the CHOOSE PATH menu.  This menu will
 allow you to store up to 20 of your favorite paths for future use.  If
 at anytime you were to swap a disk in either drive A or B, then by using
 the ESC key, you can update the path window.

 Using this option allows the user to specify from one to sixteen
 different extentions to be display in the window.  So you could show all
 files that have an extention of PC1, PC2, PC3, PI1, PI2, PI3, SPC, and
 so on all in one window at one time.  To my knowlege this is the only
 program that allows the user this much flexibility in one package.  If
 you do not find the extention you are looking for among the ones
 provided you can enter it on a small command line at the top of the
 screen.  To look for programs with the first four letters of TEXT you
 would enter TEXT*.* and only these files would be display in the window.
 One other nice feature is the ability to include or exclude all files
 with certain extentions, so that you only see the file extentions that
 you are looking for.  With the release of TOS 1.4 a bug was fixed that
 toggled an archive bit that indicated if a file had been modified since
 it was last backed-up.  In MAXIFILE you now have the ability to see all
 files that have the archive bit set.  You also have the ability to see
 all files that were created or moved before or after a certain date.

 Across the bottom of the window there is a row of buttons.  The first
 control is actually a PAGE-FLIP control.  If there are more files in the
 selected drive or directory than can fit in the window, click on the
 right arrow in the small window and you will flip into the next window
 of files.  To get back to the first window just click on the left arrow.
 This control allows the user to pick the type of sort you would like.
 You can sort by name, extension, size or date.  The warning button
 allows the user to pick from a list of 11 different warnings.  These
 show as windows that warn the user that they can either proceed or
 cancel the present function.

 This is used to show how much room the highlighted files occupy.

 Moves the selected files from the source to the destination.  This
 button will not be highlighted unless you have selected at least one
 file from the window.

 Copies selected files from source to destination.

 Rename files with the top line of the pop-up window having the old name
 and the lower line the new name.

 This button allows the user to select:

 - TOUCH: gives the selected file or files the present time and date.
 - LOCK AND UNLOCK: lock file so that it can not be modified.
 - HIDE AND SHOW: hide files so that they will not show in the directory.
   When using MAXIFILE these files are in light lettering.
 - ARCHIVE BIT: set or clear the archive bit so that on a backup set
   files will be backed up.
 - CLEAR SELECTIONS: clears all the selected options in this window.

 This is probably the most used feature in the program.  From this window
 you can:

 - CREATE FOLDER: creates a folder on either the source or destination
   and gives the option to open the folder so that files can be copied
   directly into it.

 - FORMAT DISK: allows the user to format A, B or both, pick 9 or 10
   sector by 80 or 82 tracks, single or double sided, and if you are
   using a version of tos that supports the sector skew format, format to
   that type.  If you pick format both A and B the window will change to
   allow you to name both disks before formatting begins.  After A
   finishes formatting B will begin.

 - COPY DISK: this feature allows you to copy any unprotected disk from A
   to B.  It will first check that the destination is formatted and has
   enough room to do the operation.  If the disk is not formatted you will
   be warned that you can format the destination or cancel the operation
   all together.

 - DISK INFO: get all the information on any drive that is available.
   You will get the amount of free space, number of sectors and size of
   sector and much more.

 - PRINT DIRECTORY: you can print the source directory with full info on
   each file or you can just print the names.

 - COMMENT PATH: clicking on this button will bring up a selector button
   so that the user can pick the default path where the comment file will
   be saved.  The comments are attached to the files and the user can
   give a brief description of the file with three lines of 58 character

 - OPTION SWITCHES: From this window, located to the right, you can set
   to keep or change the time stamp when you move files, keep attributes
   on copy, show hidden files, turn write verify on or off and save the
   current paths for the source and destination.  In the file display
   option window you can show only the file and folder names (so that you
   can display 80 files instead of 48), display with sizes (the 48 file
   option), with dates or with times.  The last button allows the user to
   turn off or on the showing of dividing lines between rows of files.

 - SAVE: Allows the user to save all the option set in the previous

 The above options and features are most, but not all, of the surprises
 you will find in the MAXIFILE package.  And, as complete as this program
 is, I suspect that there will be even more surprises in future upgrades.


 After getting this program just before Christmas (in a upgrade to
 HOTWIRE (HOTWIRE PLUS)), I find that I seldom use or want to use the
 other file selectors presently on the market.  So, if you find that the
 other selectors just don't cut it, then this is one program that you owe
 it to yourself to check out!

 Codehead Software
 P.O. Box 74090
 Los Angeles, CA 90004
 P.S.: MAXIFILE by itself is $29.95 and as a package with HOTWIRE it is

                         ST STack - by Alice Amore

 PBMCHESS.ARC                Programmer:  Odisseas Kosmatos
 PLAY-BY-MODEM-CHESS allows two people to carry on a chess matchvia
 modem.  All the amenities are included.  Simply send the command to your
 modem to dial a friend's number (or put your modem in answer mode,
 whatever the case may be).
 The screen is divided into two portions, one for the chess board and
 command menu, the other a typing area so that players can type messages
 to each other.  Move a chess piece, and the move is automatically
 transmitted to your opponent.  If your screen gets corrupted by line
 noise, the other player can refresh your display by using the SEND
 command.  The previous move is always in memory, so you can back up one
 move's worth at any time.   300/1200/2400 baud is supported, although it
 is recommended that you use 300 baud.  (If you can play chess at 2400
 baud, good luck finding a worthy opponent!)
 For those who spend a lot of time thinking, games can be saved and
 reloaded.  If you put your opponent "in check", you can use the control
 key to send an audible "ding".  You can also send a "double ding" if
 your opponent falls asleep or is otherwise unresponsive.
 This chess game will not monitor the validity of your moves.  It knows
 nothing of chess.  All it does is transmit your moves, so illegal moves
 will be accepted by the computer (but probably not by your opponent).
 PBMCHESS runs in mono or medium res.  The display is very pleasant in
 mono, and acceptable in med.

 RLSGD_09.ARC        Programmer:  Jeffrey Kinzer
 This small utility, "GrafX Display", generates screen displays of
 multiple DEGAS low resolution uncompressed (.PI1) or NEOchrome pictures.
 After loading the program (low resolution only), click on the folder
 where your picture files are located.  Picture types cannot be mixed;
 choose either .PI1 or NEO pictures.  Pictures from other folders can be
 added later.  Now specify how many pictures you'd like displayed on a
 "page".  Once the first page is visible, you can cycle through various
 color combinations or flip between pages.  A directory can be "tagged"
 for future reference.
 Screen displays of multiple pictures are not esthetically pleasing.
 Your brain must fill in the blanks.  However, if you're searching around
 for a certain picture file and can't remember its filename, you should
 be able to recognize it on the screen.
 TXTDUMP2.ARC           Programmer:  Michael Shallop     ** SHAREWARE **
 TEXT DUMP is an ASCII-file printer in the form of a desk accessory.  Any
 ASCII file will print.  Page length is 55 lines, and page perforations
 will be skipped automatically.  Form feeds will be stripped.  A
 condensed pitch mode is available.
 New in this version (2.0) is batch processing.  Up to ten files of any
 length can be tagged, and the files can be located anywhere on your
 drive(s).  The printing will continue until the tenth file is done.
 TEXT DUMP may be used within other GEM-based programs, and does work
 within NeoDesk.
 The programmer did his testing on a 1040 with TOS 1.4 and had no
 problems.  However, my Mega 2 did not get along well with this program.
 Desktop corruption was rife (although leaving the desktop and then
 returning to it cleaned it up every time).  Still, for large printing
 batch jobs, it's worth the trouble.

 Programmers:  Michael Shallop   (UNCLE1.)   <-----** Shareware **
               Carl J. Hafner    (UNCLE2, UNCLE3)
 The "UNCLE" series is a group of diverse programs.  UNCLE1 is a disk
 librarian which allows you to catalog your floppies.  The resulting text
 file is in pure ASCII format and can be edited with any word processor.
 Because it uses only 66K of RAM, the program is loaded once and remains
 in memory, thus freeing up your disk drives to read directories.  Medium
 resolution only.
 Included with the disk librarian are two more programs.  One, a clock-
 setter, allows you to date-stamp a file to your liking without having to
 exit to the desktop.  The other is a floppy formatter (single/double).
 UNCLE2 contains two desk accessories.  The first, CLOCK__3, is a color-
 only clock-setting utility.  The second, UNCLERAM, offers a quick and
 easy way to check the amount of free RAM available in your system.
 UNCLE3 is silly but fun.  Use any MIDI keyboard to strobe random colors
 on your screen (color only).  Each time a key is hit, a random color
 will appear.  See how quickly you can develop a migraine.
                     PD/SHAREWARE STop - by Mark Quinn
 ============> This program is SHAREWARE
    File name:  SEQUENCE.ARC             Author:  Henry Cosh
 Program name:  16-Voice Sequencer    File type:  Application

 After dusting off a CZ-1000 and "jamming" my fingers into places good
 keyboardists would shun, I played back my "Cacraphony in C" (with the
 help of this program) and once again reaffirmed that I cannot tickle the
 ivories with the best of them.  Then I discovered that the program has
 the following features:

 o  Multi-Voice recording using separate MIDI channels or programs, split
    MIDI keyboards and/or velocity ranges.
 o  Variable resolution Map of 8 Voices on desktop continuously.
 o  Mouse click sampling of any music in the Map.
 o  Simple editing using mouse and MIDI keyboard on blocks down to hemi-
    demi-semi-quavers, with no MIDI event lists.
 o  Sections for naming passages plus setting time signature, tempo, and
    local quantization.
 o  Variable resolution metronome on any MIDI channel, program, note,
    velocity.  May be driven by external MIDI clock.

 o  Full Voice/Block copy, move, quantize, randomize, transpose, velocity

 o  Filtering of controllers, note ranges and velocity ranges on input,
    output or by direct manipulation.

 o  Undo/Redo on all operations that change the music.

 o  Through channel specification for each voice.

 o  All MIDI notes/channels/programs may be input from MIDI keyboard, or
    typed on the computer keyboard.

 o  MIDI channels and program numbers base may be selected to be 0 or 1.
 Unlike a "bare bones" sequencer I used many moons ago, this one
 displayed the music visually, in blocks.  One can Quantize, Randomize,
 Transpose, Copy, and do other STuff with these blocks.  Files may be
 merged, and there is a "PUNCH" feature which allows for more accurate

 I was successful in running the program only when its .RSC file was in
 the root directory on drive A.

 As I've stated, I am no "Kid MIDI" (the list of features is from the
 docs), but I was able to crudely navigate my way through the program
 with a little help from the manual.  If you're looking for a shareware
 sequencer, this is probably the one you're looking for.

    File name:  2COLUMNS.LZH             Author:  Jonathan Corey
 Program name:  Two Column Printer    File type:  Utility

 This program (Two Column Printer, Version 3) more than lives up to its
 name.  In addition to printing in two-column "magazine format", it can
 easily do "two-sided printing on continuous form paper", uses straight
 ASCII text files, has editable printer drivers (two Epson, Panasonic and
 Deskjet drivers are included--one may work with your printer), sports
 more features than many programs you pay for, and does its job

 I was very impressed with the output on a Deskjet.  We stepped through
 the various setup screens without consulting the manual and ended up
 with a polished-looking document.

 "Quinn's Quickies"

  Create "Hyper" computer index cards.

  Find the hidden balls by 'shooting' rays of light into the box.
  Monochrome only.

  Two programs (one's an AUTO .PRG and the other's an .ACC) that will
  free the user from printing "on the perforation".

  Makes SEEKER (the public domain KJV Bible) compatible with GODSWORD, an
  earlier download.

  Set the system date from a file.

  Get more out of the ST's sound chip with this GEM-based sound generator

                            ATARI USERS UNITE!
 Reader Commentary                (That includes you, fellow 8-bitters!)
 by Elliott John Coerper - Osan AFB, Korea
 I was working the night shift schedule here at Osan, everything was
 quiet, almost too quiet.  Chief Fishnarishski (Fish) had already dosed
 off when suddenly we were thrown out of our seats.  Bombs were going off
 and they were going off VERY close.
 Foolishly we opened our door peering outside to see what had happened.
 Two more bombs went off, this time knocking out our power.  The force of
 them knocked me against the side of our building with a loud thud.
 Meanwhile the field across from our building quickly lit up with gun
 fire.  Small flashes of light illuminated our countryside giving me a
 new meaning to "A thousand points of light".
 I know the Korean language well enough to know that someone said they
 were going to terminate us.  We instantly hustled inside, but couldn't
 lock the door behind us.  Our only viable alternative was to hide in
 Fish's office.
 Unfortunately the inevitable happened, we heard someone come in. 
 Since I had trained in the Martial Arts I decided that if I was going to
 be terminated, I was going to go down fighting!  I perched above the
 door waiting for him to enter.  In he came and down I went viciously
 putting a choke hold on him.  It worked?!!  Instantaneously his body
 went limp in my arms.  Just then the lights came back on and we learned
 I'd taken out one of our own!
 Yes, Team Spirit has hit Korea.  What is Team Spirit?  It's a combined,
 joint exercise in Korea where the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines,
 Reserve Units, and the Koreans practice together, for war.
 It's great!  Usually you never get to work side by side with people in
 different branches of the service or, for that fact, the Koreans.
 However, once a year we get to work with every branch of the service.
 Turns out, they're no different then us.
 So what does this all have to do with Atari Computers?  Everything!  We
 are all in a war together right now (The Revolution).  Aren't we trying
 to bring Atari into the mainstream?
 Unfortunately, I've heard many 8-bitters saying they will not support
 The Revolution because it's a 16-bit Revolution!  Could you imagine if
 the different services said that?  "I'm not going to war because this is
 an Artillery war", or "it's an Air Force war"... The only way we win
 wars, is by working and fighting TOGETHER!  It took every branch of the
 service to win in Panama.
 Whatever success that Atari 8-bit has had over the past three years is
 due largely in part to the ST line.  Had Atari relied only upon the 8-
 bit market and not developed (or continue to develop) the 16-bit line,
 we would not have an Atari Corporation to kick around.  And, whatever
 success we are going to have in the upcoming years, is going to rely
 upon the success of Atari Corporation.  As they succeed, so will the 8-
 bit market.  
 If you think other third party companies will support us if Atari
 Corporation goes out of business, just look at who is supporting Adam
 Computers!  How about the Timex-Sinclair....or ColecoVision?
 The only way we are going to see new products for our 8-bit computers is
 to support The Revolution.  Let them know that we are proud owners of 8-
 bit Computers!  Write a letter or two or even three, but insure they
 know that you own an 8-bit.
 Let's try something, let's all write off to Andy Rooney (if he's working
 this week) and Paul Harvey.  We'll tell them about The Revolution.  If
 you know how to write, write a scenario for them.  I can imagine them
 sitting behind a computer.  What's this mouse thing, it doesn't look
 like a mouse?  And what is this thing about WYSIWYG software.  Why don't
 they have software that allows you to see what you get?  Why do they
 call these things "Floppy Diskettes?" (clunk, clunk), they don't seem
 too floppy to me.  And what is TOS, am I supposed to toss this computer
 in the air to make it work?
 Come on, be imaginative.  We are a force to be reckoned with, if we get
 involved.  Just one letter WILL help!  Well, that's it for now,
 remember, always keep the Faith, support The Revolution and always talk
 up Atari Computers.


                             PIRACY RESPONSE
 by Ron Kovacs
 Last week I published an article written by Joseph Hicswa a fellow JACG 
 member about piracy.  This article was presented as reader commentary 
 and did not reflect those of this publication.
 The article was J. Hicswa's comments and feeling about piracy which 
 brought about the responses that follow my commentary below.
 The policy of this publication is to present news, reviews and feedback 
 from our readers.  In the nearly five years we have been producing 
 weekly online magazines, we have always allowed our readers to comment 
 and will present opposing points of view the following week.  From the 
 little research I have done on reader commentaries, I found that we have
 gone atleast 4 straight weeks with opposing and responding commentary on
 a particular issue.
 The content of these commentaries have been varied and outspoken at 
 times but all published because we feel it is important to pass along 
 our readers comments when they are submitted.  We do not necessarily 
 agree with all the comments received and if they are out of line they 
 probably would not appear.  To date, I have not received a letter marked
 as reader commentary and not published it.
 I will not edit or rephrase a readers commentary and will continue the
 policy.  I correct spelling errors only.  Lastly, we do not receive
 letters every week so this really is not a regular incident.
 To balance the comments of last week's article, I have reprinted 
 messages from our designated area on GEnie and from email where a reader 
 responded with a text file.
 Category 31,  Topic 2 Message 43        Sat Mar 10, 1990
 D.A.BRUMLEVE                 at 00:28 CST
 Wow, your "Reader Commentary" by Joseph E. Hicswa had me going for a
 while, until I realized how easy life was going to be from now on.  As a
 writer of both pd and commercial offerings (like most ST programmers),
 I've noticed that my commercial programs bring in income that allows me
 to buy better development tools and equipment and attend Atari shows,
 whereas my pd programs do not.  But now that I've embraced Mr. Hicswa's
 philosophy, I won't need money to buy these things anymore!
 I mean, he figured that because I use Charles Johnson's Pinhead 1.2,
 Charles has the _right_ to use my Kidpublisher Professional at no
 charge...And not just Charles!  If I use Charles' program, _everybody_
 who has ever given free help has the right to to use my commercial
 programs at no charge!

 And, conversely, since _I_ have published some two dozen freely-
 distributed programs, _I_ have the right to use HotWire at no charge!
 And not just me, but _everybody_ ...

 Ja, makes sense, doesn't it?  I've given, so now it's time to get!

 This strikes me as a singularly remarkable philosophy.  There is
 apparently no need for me to write commercial programs at all; after
 all, I won't need to buy anything.  I'll put them all out pd, even the
 ones I spent months and months on!  Then when I need to improve my
 compiler so that I can share better programs, I'm supposed to just take
 it!  After all, GFA _owes_ it to me.  And when I need to publish a
 poster, I'll just take a dtp package.  After all, ISD _owes_ it to me.
 When I need to improve my equipment to make better programs, I'll just
 take it: my dealer, Atari, the folks in Taiwan who put it together--they
 owe me plenty!  When I need to go to Toronto or Anaheim to a show, I'll
 just get on an airplane and go, open a hotel room door and settle in...
 These guys _must_ owe me plenty, I've given so much to so many!

 Yes, I've given enough, and the scales are tilted heavily in my
 direction.  Hmm...Looks a little light on Joseph E. Hicswa's end!  Let's
 see...Do you suppose Joseph E. Hicswa has something I want?  Maybe a CD
 player or a Lynx?  A Mercedes?  I've got a _right_ to that stuff!

 Will he hand it over?  You bet he will!  Joe's a generous guy.  Just
 look how freely he shares my stuff with others!

 Of course, since I won't need money, I won't need to program anymore,
 either.  Oh, yeah, I've got some 70 unexplored program ideas on my idea
 board, but it'll be a long time before the debt due me is repaid, and
 the ideas will wait until then.  Joe and Joe's kids and Joe's grandkids
 won't know what they missed, and they won't owe me a damn thing.
 Message 45        Sat Mar 10, 1990  C.F.JOHNSON  at 09:01 PST
 I was appalled at the "article" by Joseph Hicswa in ZNET 510.  Whoever
 decided to print this semi-literate bunch of ravings made an extremely
 unwise decision.

 I personally will NOT be downloading or reading ZNET until this totally
 absurd pile of junk is refuted by the editors.
 It's absolutely, mind-bogglingly irresponsible to publish an article
 ADVOCATING piracy (that's right!), as ST developers are leaving for
 other computers at an alarming rate, and once-loyal users are selling
 their systems in droves.

 I'm disgusted with ZNET.

    - Charles F. Johnson
      CodeHead Software

 Message 53        Sun Mar 11, 1990 Z-NET [John Nagy]  at 01:32 EST
 LOTS of "guest editorials" and "reader viewpoints" and "commentaries"
 are seen as incoherent and irresponsible ravings by those who disagree.
 Abortion, racial matters, religion, etc. fill the editorial pages of
 respected newspapers and the minutes at the end of newscasts everywhere.
 Many of the positions I hear and read being advocated are repulsive to
 me... just as the concepts I read in Mr. Hicswa's commentary about
 Piracy are repulsive and "irrational" to me.  But just as I won't stop
 reading the LA TIMES nor watching 60 minutes (Rooney, you know....), I
 don't expect that Hicswa's commentary (clearly marked as READER
 COMMENTARY) should make you drop Z*NET, Charles.

 If you, Charles, or anyone else here thinks that this is the ONLY person
 on the planet who has constructed a rationalization for piracy, you must
 not visit this planet often.

 Mr. Hicswa's commentary will have served a lofty purpose if even a few
 people read it and say "that's looney", then wonder about how their own
 behavior and reasoning on piracy compares.

 Obviously, the most valuable result of publishing an outrageous
 commentary is the well reasoned and effectively presented flip side of
 the matter that inevitably comes from other readers.  Thanks a LOT, DOT,
 your initial comments are both thoroughly entertaining and quite
 powerful.  LOTS more effective than, for example, saying you didn't like
 it and would hold your breath til we apologised.
 Message 57        Sun Mar 11, 1990 LEPULLEY   at 10:46 MST

 I believe that a publishers 'neutrality' ceases when he publishes an
 article/guest editorial that promotes illegal activities (would you
 publish an article on how to make a home-made pipe-bomb?).

 While Mr. Hicswa has every right to his personal opinions and Zmag does
 have the right to post those opinions if they so wish, I believe that
 Zmag was very remiss in not putting a disclaimer of some type at the
 bottom of the article (i.e. maybe something like "We do not condone nor
 endorse piracy in any form or for any reason.  Mr. Hicswa's opinions are
 his alone.")

 But his article did serve as a prime example of what lengths that some
 people will stoop to defend their piracy (I thought the article was a
 spoof at first...I thought I'd heard every rational possible for piracy
 but his article proved to me that I hadn't).

 (LL)oyd Pulley

 Message 60        Sun Mar 11, 1990 C.F.JOHNSON   at 14:19 PST
 John Nagy,

 There are a couple of large differences between the discussions on
 abortion, race, religion and other matters that one finds in newspapers
 and on television, and the "commentary" by Mr. Hicswa.
 First, no responsible newspaper gives a forum to every random crazy who
 is able to manipulate a pen (or a computer) well enough to write down
 his/her "ideas".  Certain journalistic standards have to be met before
 ANY article will be published in ANY newspaper.  Mr. Hicswa's
 "commentary" is so full of misused words, misspellings, and horrible
 grammar that it wouldn't even be published in the 'Letters' column of
 any newspaper with which I'm familiar.  An editor would glance at it
 once, and then immediately file it in the garbage...with all the other
 letters from psychos. 

 Second, do you honestly believe that any newspaper or television station
 would give column space or air time to a person who advocates the theft
 of other people's property, because it's somehow (in some nebulous,
 unspecified way) _good_ for society?  Get real, John.  If you believe
 that's the way "free speech" works, then you're living in another
 dimension.  You don't see articles in newspapers or on 60 Minutes
 advocating pederasty or rape or murder, do you?  Is that because the
 people who think these activities are OK and want to promote them (and
 they DO exist) are having their freedom restricted?  No -- it's because
 it's absurd to espouse viewpoints like that in a civilized society, and
 RESPONSIBLE journalists are aware of this.  Just as it's absurd and
 destructive to give a forum in an ST-oriented publication to someone
 (Mr.  Hicswa) who wants to urge all other ST users to go out and pirate
 everything they can.

 As Dorothy said, there _are_ some intelligent arguments that can be made
 against the "ownership" concept as it regards computer software.
 Richard Stallman of the Free Software Foundation talks and writes a lot
 about these issues.  Perhaps Mr. Hicswa once read something about
 Stallman and the FSF, and seized on it as a great justification to steal
 software, or maybe his "views" are strictly his own creation.  I don't
 know, and don't really care.  There isn't one "argument" in the
 "article" even worth trying to refute. 

 What disturbs me is the fact that ZNET will publish this kind of drivel,
 and then attempt to defend it as "free speech".  With support for the ST
 rapidly dwindling, users abandoning Atari, and Atari itself seemingly
 oblivious to the mess they've made of the US market, publishing this
 "commentary" is the moral equivalent of yelling "FIRE!" in a crowded

 In any case, just as ZNET has the right to publish stuff like this if
 they choose, I have the right to choose NOT to download and read ZNET.
 A right which I plan to exercise from now on. 

 - Charles

 READER REPLY  by  Jan Dembowski

 Remarkable.  Usually the content of ZNET is really very good but in this
 most recent issue I read something that really made me wonder and ask
 myself "What is ZNET saying?".  I am reffering to a childish tirade in
 issue 510 by Joseph Hicswa.  Then I re-read it and saw that it was a
 Reader Commentary.  So in the spirit of "Reader Commentary's" I would
 like to make a reply.
 Is Mr. Hicswa living on the same planet as I?  He says that he is sick
 and tired of software manufacturers complaining about piracy.  "Show me
 the programmer who has never used a public domain program, who has not
 received FREE help from a friend, fellow employee, computer club member,
 or book from a public library."  Ah.  I suppose that Bell Labs should
 not charge anything except costs of manufacturing electronic hardware
 since they "received FREE help from a friend, fellow employee"?  That
 makes sense.  Hey, maybe we could also get any research done by
 engineers placed in the public domain.  They used free Calculus and
 Euclidean Geometry that was NOT there work but done by earlier
 Let me explain something that Mr. Hicswa does not seem to understand.
 The designers of commercial software are ENGINEERS.  Many of them have
 studied programing in college and have worked hard to learn what they
 know.  Would he go to a professional architect and say "Design my home
 for me and I'll only pay for the cost of materials.  You owe a debt to
 all the classical architects and pioneers in the field.  So PAY UP!"
 Have I missed something in his logic...?  Then he goes on to stating
 that "Computers are one of the greatest things that befall Humanity.
 Our progress is being accelerated like never before."  What an excellent
 excuse for PIRATING.  Copy software!  Distribute a developers work!
 After all those "disk mongers" just "now want to get wealthy for their
 labors" "from someone elses freebees"!  And the nicest thing about that
 argument is that by PIRATING we are advancing humanities progress like
 never before.
 I wonder if Mr. Hicswa ever bothered to meet a developer?  He must
 believe that they all are "rich" and drive sports cars.  Or did he
 really meet one and saw that they all have horns and pointy tails?  Hey,
 those devils are keeping the costs of software out of the hands of many
 poor souls.  I am thoroughly disgusted at his attitude: it sounds like
 the noise that a little child makes when his hands are slapped when told
 he can't have an expensive toy.  He seems to feel that software
 manufacturers owe people something.  Why?  Because he purchased a
 computer, and they OWE him software?  If Mr. Hicswa wants to bring
 software to handicapped people then instead of crying about the costs
 why doesn't he do something like starting a fund to buy software for
 people who cannot?  No... a child would never do something like that.
 A child would rather push the problem into the laps of others and claim
 its their fault.  In this case the child is Mr. Hicswa and the other's
 are the software manufacturers.
 Mr. Hicswa ends his nonsense with a suggestion that piracy laws should
 be repealed.  Piracy laws?  They are call "copyright laws" and they are
 not going to be repealed.  But I can hope that he pursues this and is
 caught and is faced with the full extent of the law.

 Z*Net Online is a weekly online magazine covering the Atari community.
 Opinions and commentary are those of the individual authors and  do not
 reflect those of Z*NET or Rovac Industries.  Z*NET and Z*NET ONLINE are
 copyright (c)1990 by Rovac Industries.   Reprint  permission is granted
 as long as ZNET ONLINE  and  the author is included at the top of the
 article.  Reprinted articles are not be edited without permission.
 ZNET ONLINE                               Atari News and Reviews FIRST!
                Copyright (c)1990 Rovac Industries, Inc..
 ZNET ONLINE ISSUE #511                               VOLUME 5 NUMBER 11



Return to message index